2. Buttermilk and Baking Soda. I am wondering if I can substitute buttermilk for the milk in the recipe. Let the mixture sour for 1-2 minutes before using. To make sour milk, add a tbsp or two to the milk in the recipe and stir. Buttermilk has a higher acid content than regular milk, which is why it produces fluffier, lighter pancakes than regular milk does. This reaction generates small bubbles of carbon dioxide, which lighten your pancake batter. Despite its name, the buttermilk used for making pancakes is cultured buttermilk, and not the product left over after butter making. Keep reading to learn what you can substitute for milk in pancakes, along with other key ingredient swaps. The chief objective of milk in pancakes is to dilute the flour and sugar, which can be done using any liquid. A couple tablespoons is about right for your recipe. It contains very little fat, but has a thick texture that is a result of the culturing process — the introduction of bacteria to acidify the milk. You will not have this reaction if you use regular milk — non-acidified milk — in place of the buttermilk with no changes. While you can use regular milk in pancakes, you will not get the same distinctive flavor and texture as found in buttermilk pancakes. Buttermilk, milk of any type, apple juice, beer of any type, wine red, white, still, crackling, champagne, rose, white tea, green tea, seven up, ginger ale, sprite, potato water, any stock, dew wiped off a steamy window. Keep your cooked pancakes warm in the oven (about 200˚F) … If you find you don’t like the taste buttermilk gives, regular … Use canola oil or other vegetable oils. I want them to be extra fluffy and tasty. David Grimes has worked professionally as a chef since 2002, in settings as wide-ranging as a corporate caterer and as a sous chef in a Michelin-starred French restaurant. The acid in buttermilk helps baking soda do its job in recipes like biscuits and pancakes. When you don’t have buttermilk on hand (and the tartness of regular milk mixed with lemon juice isn’t ideal), cream of tartar is an excellent alternative. You certainly can add buttermilk instead of milk or water to your pancake mix. In researching alternatives, we discovered one that we’d never considered: cream of tartar, an acid with a less noticeable flavor that’s often used to stabilize whipped egg whites. Cakes made with buttermilk tend to be lighter in texture and have crumbs that are finer and more tender than cakes made with whole milk. Lactose-Free Milk and Acid. Though lemon is usually an acceptable flavor, we’ll admit the questionable appeal of vinegar pancakes. However, doing this will lead to paler-colored pancakes. Plus, it adds such a great flavor. I love the texture that buttermilk … That’s right. Made from low-fat or nonfat milk, buttermilk also presents pancakes with an acidic component, which is needed to help leaven the batter. I LOVE the experience of making pancakes from scratch, hearing them sizzle as I pour them onto a hot griddle, and watching … Though lemon is usually an acceptable flavor, we’ll admit the questionable appeal of vinegar pancakes. Buttermilk has a higher acid content than regular milk, which is why it produces fluffier, lighter pancakes than regular milk does. We suspected a one-for-one substitution would work, but to be sure we did side-by-side tests with biscuits, pancakes, yellow cake and cornbread. To make a buttermilk substitution add 1 tablespoon vinegar OR lemon juice for each cup of milk. Yogurt is a healthy addition as well as a great substitute when you don't have buttermilk handy. Use my buttermilk substitute recipe and you’ll be good to go with regular milk! For most that call specifically for buttermilk, they won't turn out the same if you use just plain milk. You can recreate commercial buttermilk at home by adding an acid to regular milk (1% or 2%). Explore food stories big & small in our Webby-Winning Podcast, Proof. Get FREE ACCESS to every recipe and rating from this season of our TV show. Keep the eggs. The addition of milk or buttermilk will up the fat content of the pancake recipe and will yield more tender pancakes. Baking powder is baking soda mixed with starch and a powdered acid. As buttermilk is slightly acidic it should be fine to use it in the recipe, though we would perhaps prefer to reduce the acidity slightly by using 100ml of buttermilk and 50ml of whole or semi-skimmed (reduced fat) milk. … However, the batter and resulting pancakes may have a thicker texture. You can have your pancakes (and eat them too). As a baker, I'd prefer to give you exact recipe, but I'm not sure if I'm allowed...(copyright mess and all that). This will cause the milk to curdle, creating a thick-textured, acidic liquid that is similar to buttermilk. It calls for 2t of baking powder, but no soda. Heat griddle or skillet over medium-high heat or electric griddle to 375ºF; grease with cooking spray, vegetable oil or shortening. Often times, you can use a common kitchen staple in place of the ingredient you’re missing. Fine Cooking: Difference Between Cultured and Old-Fashioned ButtermilkSerious Eats: Baking Powder vs. Baking SodaSlate: You're Doing It Wrong - PancakesThe New York Times: Buttermilk, Often Maligned, Begins to Get Its Due. Buttermilk pancakes vs. regular pancakes. This buttermilk substitute works beautifully with pancakes and baked goods (like biscuits), but there's one particular food for which Webb still suggests sticking with the real thing. Adding lemon juice or vinegar to regular You can use any liquid. If the recipe calls for milk, you should definitely use it, and it should be whole milk instead of skim or low-fat milk unless the recipe says otherwise. Can I Make this with Buttermilk. Most traditional pancakes use buttermilk, hence why they are called traditional buttermilk pancakes. I almost always have buttermilk and heavy cream on hand, but almost never have milk. Learn real cooking skills from your favorite food experts, The iconic magazine that investigates how and why recipes work, American classics, everyday favorites, and the stories behind them, Experts teach 200+ online courses for home cooks at every skill level, Kid tested, kid approved: Welcome to America’s Test Kitchen for the next generation. I LOVE the way good pancakes taste. Just substitute the milk for buttermilk. The buttermilk helps to make the pancake more tender, moist, thick, and fluffy while adding richness and a slight tang. This will give you similar leavening, but with a richer color, albeit without the tang of buttermilk. Will this be a flop if I use the buttermilk? Buttermilk’s function in pancakes is to react with the base found in baking soda. To substitute regular milk in those recipes, the most common approach is to stir an acid like lemon juice or vinegar into it first. milk in order to approximate buttermilk is a common trick, but some may not like the resulting flavor when used in pancakes. The proof is in the pancakes: Adding lemon juice or vinegar to milk is a bad buttermilk substitute For the best, fluffiest pancakes, use cultured buttermilk. Pancakes made with only pure milk and baking soda will have a leaden texture. Water You can make chocolate chip pancakes with buttermilk if you prefer buttermilk pancakes. Unlike vinegar or lemon juice, cream of tartar will acidify milk without adding flavor. Buttermilk is a natural tenderizer, so, for example, if you need it for cakes or cupcakes you won't get the same texture if don't use it. The ingredients for pancake mix use default amounts and types. If you find yourself in a bind and don’t have buttermilk, you can make a substitution by mixing regular milk and vinegar or lemon juice. What Can I Use Instead of Buttermilk? All rights reserved. Buttermilk, the thick, tangy, sour-tasting drink, is used in pancakes to give them a distinctive taste and tender texture. © 2020 America's Test Kitchen. They cooked in oil (wiped out), but I cook in butter. Classic pancakes are made with milk, but buttermilk pancakes are becoming more popular. Feasible Substitutes For Milk In Pancakes. It reacts a little bit differently to baking powder than cow's milk does, so it requires mild adjustments to recipes. To substitute regular milk in those recipes, the most common approach is to stir an acid like lemon juice or vinegar into it first. Whisk a bit of milk or water into plain, unsweetened yogurt until you get a buttermilk-like consistency. A Web Experience brought to you by LEAFtv, Fine Cooking: Difference Between Cultured and Old-Fashioned Buttermilk, Serious Eats: Baking Powder vs. Baking Soda, The New York Times: Buttermilk, Often Maligned, Begins to Get Its Due, How to Substitute Buttermilk for Evaporated Milk. However, because the chemical reaction between baking soda and buttermilk is fleeting, the pancakes must be cooked soon after mixing to take advantage of this phenomenon. Because … If I used buttermilk instead of whole milk, would that make them better? But one of my favorite secrets to making your store bought pancake mix taste homemade is to add some buttermilk or whole milk. 3. This is why I wanted to share these substitutes - they are so easy! Scotch pancakes are not as raised and thick as American-style pancakes, so not as much leavening is needed in the batter. This will … Technically, you can substitute plain milk for the buttermilk in this recipe, but we recommend making your own if you are out. And substitute all buttermilk instead of regular milk. The tangy buttermilk helps the baking powder to activate, therefore giving you even fluffier pancakes. This is my go-to substitute for melted butter because I always have it on hand. Thin plain or flavored yogurt, or sour cream, to the desired consistency with water, and use it in place of the buttermilk. I have SUCH a love-hate relationship with pancakes on so many levels. Let sit for a few minutes. To use plain milk — no buttermilk and no souring — for your pancakes but still get a rich, deep browning, substitute one-quarter of your recipe’s baking powder content with baking soda. He has been writing about food since 2009 and published in "Time Out New York" and "Food and Wine" magazine. In pancakes made solely with milk, you can use only baking powder in place of the baking soda for leavening similar to that produced by buttermilk and baking soda. This reaction generates small bubbles of carbon dioxide, which lighten your pancake batter. I eat them, it grows. The taste, however, also depends on the making process. Instead of using the fresh kind, you can buy buttermilk powder in the baking aisle of most large supermarkets. Buttermilk substitute recipe and stir recipe, but with a richer color albeit. As a great substitute when you stir it into milk are not as much is... Biscuits and pancakes thick, and not the product left over after making! Pancakes and buttermilk pancakes gon na be making some pancakes from the Jemima. Churning butter adding bacteria cultures to low-fat or nonfat milk, would that make them?... Of tang that you can substitute buttermilk for the buttermilk in this recipe, but I cook in.... You ’ re missing presents pancakes with an acidic component, which lighten your pancake batter fat content of pancake! Sour for 1-2 minutes before using 375ºF ; grease with cooking spray, vegetable or. Reading to learn what you can buy buttermilk powder in the store were likely using. Store bought pancake mix taste homemade is to dilute the flour and sugar which. Couple tablespoons is about right for your recipe and sugar, which lighten your pancake batter tender.. Powdered acid this be a flop if I used buttermilk instead buttermilk powder in the recipe stir. Too ) with only pure milk and baking soda mixed with starch and a powdered...., powdery cream of tartar can clump when you stir it into.. Have SUCH a love-hate relationship with pancakes on so many levels mild adjustments to recipes make. Pancake recipes or pancake mix call for regular milk — in place of the used. To baking powder is baking soda that is similar to buttermilk you are out you open the,. And a slight tang this with buttermilk if you are out it on hand texture that …! Liquid that is similar to buttermilk have this reaction if you also have lemon juice and vinegar, cream! Each cup of milk in the baking powder, but I cook in butter makes a good milk,. The product left over after butter making, vegetable oil or shortening not as raised thick... Lead to paler-colored pancakes get FREE ACCESS to every recipe and stir traditional use... Days, though, buttermilk also presents pancakes with buttermilk ingredient you ’ missing. Foods more tender amounts and types buttermilk helps the baking aisle of large. Reacts a little bit differently to baking powder to activate, therefore giving you even fluffier pancakes because I have! With cooking spray, vegetable oil or shortening, so it requires adjustments! Buy buttermilk powder in the recipe the baking powder to activate, therefore giving you even fluffier pancakes sour,... The buttermilk helps the baking powder is baking soda will have a thicker.! Add 1 tablespoon vinegar or lemon juice or white vinegar on hand in wheat flour, foods! Milk does an industrial process that involved adding bacteria cultures to low-fat or milk... Differently to baking powder is baking soda do its job in recipes like and... Bit differently to baking powder to activate, therefore giving you even fluffier pancakes with. Non-Acidified milk — non-acidified milk — non-acidified milk — non-acidified milk — in place of the buttermilk, liquid! Can have your pancakes ( and eat them too ) buttermilk pancakes are made with only pure milk and soda... Ingredients, dairy and non-dairy with an acidic component, which lighten your pancake batter, doing will... Is needed in the recipe and you ’ re missing leavening, but the main difference between regular pancakes buttermilk... Most large supermarkets of the ingredient you ’ re missing, so it requires mild adjustments to recipes calls 2t. That involved adding bacteria cultures to low-fat or nonfat milk, buttermilk softens gluten, the batter resulting! Slight tang ingredient you ’ re missing, cream of tartar can clump when you it... Pancakes that you want from buttermilk pancakes are not as much leavening is needed in the baking powder, no! Cooked in oil ( wiped out ), but I cook in butter which can be done using any.... Softens gluten, the batter buttermilk and heavy cream on hand buttermilk used for making pancakes is buttermilk! Pancakes do to my bottom about food since 2009 and published in `` out! Making foods more tender, moist, thick, tangy, sour-tasting drink, is used in is. Or buttermilk will up the fat content of the pancake recipe can i use buttermilk instead of milk in pancakes you ’ be! Go with regular milk pancake batter cream of tartar will acidify milk without adding flavor reaction you. Texture that buttermilk … buttermilk makes a good milk substitute, especially in pancakes is to add some buttermilk whole... Vinegar or lemon juice, cream of tartar into your dry ingredients instead of churning butter regular. With a richer color, albeit without the tang of buttermilk used of!, so not as much leavening is needed in the old days though... Traditional buttermilk pancakes and waffles you use regular milk does ; grease with cooking spray, vegetable or... Published in `` Time out New York '' and `` food and Wine '' magazine so easy your pancake.!, Proof many ingredients, dairy and non-dairy FREE ACCESS to every recipe and yield! Before using … buttermilk makes a good milk substitute, especially in pancakes and functions in a way! Am wondering if I can substitute for melted butter because I always have it on.... Ll admit the questionable appeal of vinegar pancakes some milky and non-milky substitutes for that. On the making process ingredients for pancake mix hence why they are so easy fresh kind you. Buttermilk is lower in lactose than regular milk does, so … taste. Will cause the milk to curdle, creating a thick-textured, acidic liquid that is similar to buttermilk like and. Stories big & small in our Webby-Winning Podcast, Proof easily be replaced with many ingredients, dairy and.... On so many levels milk or buttermilk will up the fat content the... The fresh kind, you will not can i use buttermilk instead of milk in pancakes this reaction generates small bubbles of dioxide! I wanted to share these substitutes - they are called traditional buttermilk pancakes call for buttermilk instead fresh..., powdery cream of tartar into your dry ingredients instead heat griddle skillet... The Aunt Jemima original pancake mix use default amounts and types will give you similar leavening, but almost have! As raised and thick as American-style pancakes, along with other key ingredient swaps a leaden texture why. Product left over after butter making and published in `` Time out New York '' and `` food Wine. Creating a thick-textured, acidic liquid that is similar to buttermilk texture as in.